Forever (Un)stable Regimes? The Comparison of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan Cover Image

Forever (Un)stable Regimes? The Comparison of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan
Forever (Un)stable Regimes? The Comparison of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan

Author(s): Peter Plenta
Subject(s): Social Sciences
Published by: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL & Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II
Keywords: Kazakhstan; Kyrgyzstan; political institutions; economy; security

Summary/Abstract: Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan are following different trajectories in terms of stability and leadership. On the one hand, the Kazakh president, Nazarbayev, successfully manages issues within the country, on the other hand Kyrgyzstan has fallen into a period of protests, revolutions and instability in 2005–2010. The article focuses on three dimensions in order to explain this difference: political performance, economic performance and security performance. Despite a huge contrast in economic conditions, Kyrgyz presidents could be successful in maintaining their positions. However, the use of similar tools like in Kazakhstan in political and security areas failed because of state-building effort almost in the whole history of independent Kyrgyzstan.

  • Issue Year: 43/2015
  • Issue No: 1
  • Page Range: 23-42
  • Page Count: 20