Medical Malpractice: The Standard of Care and the Realities of Healthcare Systems
Medical Malpractice: The Standard of Care and the Realities of Healthcare Systems

Summary/Abstract: Medical malpractice represents a critical convergence of tort law and clinical practice, requiring a balance between patient rights and professional protection. This paper examines the standard of care – the legal benchmark of reasonableness for determining negligence – and how its application is complicated by the systemic constraints of modern healthcare. From a legal perspective, we analyze the evolution of the standard of care from the locality rule to contemporary national standards, highlighting the difficulty of defining competence amidst rapid technological shifts. We investigate the judicial reliance on expert testimony, arguing that the law often adopts an ideal system fallacy by assuming practitioners possess total autonomy and unlimited resources. The research further explores systemic impediments such as understaffing and burnout, which create a performance gap between theoretical legal requirements and clinical reality. Through comparative jurisprudence, we examine how courts address the tension between systemic negligence and individual liability. Finally, the paper proposes a context-aware legal framework, advocating for a nuanced understanding of systemic factors to ensure genuine patient protection without imposing an unsustainable burden of liability on healthcare professionals.

• Details
• Contents