The Fall of Rhetoric, the Rise of Eristics, that is, Beautiful Theory and Evil Practices Cover Image

Upadek retoryki, wzlot erystyki, czyli piękna teoria i niecne praktyki
The Fall of Rhetoric, the Rise of Eristics, that is, Beautiful Theory and Evil Practices

Author(s): Tomasz Goban-Klas
Subject(s): Social Sciences, Media studies, Communication studies
Published by: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL & Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II
Keywords: eristics; rhetoric; contemporary media; public sphere

Summary/Abstract: The contemporary political scene, especially the public debate, is dominated by eristic forms of argumentation, i.e., verbal fights per fas et nefas — by any persuasive means, not only regardless of ethics and respect for dignity of adversary, but also regardless of the adequacy of arguments. Although classical rhetoric is not considered by everyone (following Plato’s example) as the best means of achieving the truth (here the Socratic dialectic and dialogic method are considered more appropriate), the effective and honest rhetoric is based on reliable arguments, although it does not avoid pathos, and therefore emotions. Social media do not improve, but worsen the quality of public debate, and in turn, the constantly increasing flood of insignificant, not to mention even false media information, does not form a conscious citizen, but a political ignorant. Father Professor Leon Dyczewski, with his life-long scientific and didactic activity in the field of media and journalism, criticized this trend of degradation of the media, the public sphere and journalism, even at a time when it was not dominant, but inferior, or rather marginal. Especially now, his works deserve all the more remembrance and continuation not only as a form in memoriam, but also in the form of a creative and updating continuation.

  • Issue Year: 49/2021
  • Issue No: 1
  • Page Range: 73-84
  • Page Count: 12
  • Language: Polish