What Is It Like to Be a Bat? Reflections upon the Reading of Thomas Nagel’s Essay Cover Image

Jak to jest być nietoperzem? Refleksje przy lekturze eseju Thomasa Nagela
What Is It Like to Be a Bat? Reflections upon the Reading of Thomas Nagel’s Essay

Author(s): Dobrosława Wężowicz-Ziółkowska
Subject(s): Philosophy, Language studies, Language and Literature Studies, Applied Linguistics, Special Branches of Philosophy, Cognitive linguistics, Philosophy of Language
Published by: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego
Keywords: Nagel; bat; anthropodenial; anthropomorphism; language; cognition

Summary/Abstract: The article asks questions about the human cognitive abilities – how it is to be an animal of a species different from one’s own. Using as a basis the doubts of the philosopher Thomas Nagel, the author proceeds to discuss the standpoint of ethnologists Frans de Waal and Konrad Lorenz, who accept the limitations of the human cognitive apparatus and language, with the help of which we describe what we call the “animal.” The author suggests that the problem of contemporary humanities and animal studies lies not in anthropodenial, but in anthropomorphism, rooted in the centrism typical of our species, which seems impossible to overcome. The author also proposes a thesis that the way to overcome this issue is for people to gain knowledge about these limitations. This knowledge, supported by interspecies empathy, developed in the process of coevolution of animal species (humans being one of them), is the most effective tool of heuristics.

  • Issue Year: 2015
  • Issue No: 1
  • Page Range: 83-94
  • Page Count: 12
  • Language: Polish