Recenzenci w odwoławczych postępowaniach awansowych w nauce
Reviewers in appeal proceedings for granting academic degrees

Summary/Abstract: In proceedings for granting academic degrees and titles, reviewers play a significant role, assuming various functions and responsibilities. A distinct category, however, comprises reviewers who are mandatorily appointed in appellate proceedings, the role of whom is not explicitly regulated by law. This regulatory gap gives rise to numerous issues, including the assignment to such reviewers of tasks for which they are neither adequately prepared. The article offers an analysis of the current legal framework in this area and assesses the procedural relevance of opinions rendered by these reviewers, particularly in light of the characteristics and guiding principles of such proceedings, as well as the judicial review. The study employs the dogmatic-legal method, includes a review of relevant legal literature and case law, and formulates de lege ferenda proposals.

• Details
• Contents