GLOSS ON THE SENTENCE CORAM JĘDRASZEWSKI ON THE 4 MAY 2023 DECLARING THE MARRIAGE INVALID ON THE GROUNDS OF MALICIOUS DECEPTION (APPROVING) Cover Image

GLOSA DO WYROKU CORAM JĘDRASZEWSKI Z DNIA 4 MAJA 2023 ROKU STWIERDZAJĄCEGO NIEWAŻNOŚĆ MAŁŻEŃSTWA Z TYTUŁU PODSTĘPNEGO WPROWADZENIA W BŁĄD (APROBUJĄCA)
GLOSS ON THE SENTENCE CORAM JĘDRASZEWSKI ON THE 4 MAY 2023 DECLARING THE MARRIAGE INVALID ON THE GROUNDS OF MALICIOUS DECEPTION (APPROVING)

Author(s): Marcin Wolczko
Subject(s): Canon Law / Church Law, Philosophy of Law, Court case
Published by: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL & Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II
Keywords: malice; briefer process; CAIS; vetitum; transsexualism; sex reversal;

Summary/Abstract: The subject of the gloss is the sentence declaring the invalidity of a marriage issued in briefer process by a diocesan bishop on the grounds of malicious deception. The marriage of the parties was declared invalid due to the deception of both parties by the woman's mother. The subject of the deception was the woman's actual male genetic sex. The problem in determining the defendant's sex arose from a rare genetic disorder: "complete androgen insensitivity syndrome," which causes somatic sex to be inconsistent with genetic sex. In the second part of the gloss, the author analyses the legal effects of the vetitum prohibiting the defendant from entering into a new marriage without the consent of the ordinary of the place and presents the possibilities for granting such consent.

  • Issue Year: 35/2025
  • Issue No: 4
  • Page Range: 109-123
  • Page Count: 15
  • Language: Polish
Toggle Accessibility Mode