A marbled epistemology: embodied modeling at the intersection of art and science
A marbled epistemology: embodied modeling at the intersection of art and science

Summary/Abstract: This article argues that water marbling affords genuine, non-propositional understanding - tacit, affective, and embodied - thereby strengthening aesthetic cognitivism. Marbling - floating pigments on water, manipulating them into patterns, and transferring them onto paper - renders visible the dynamics of fluid motion, resistance, and emergence. Drawing on philosophical accounts of fictional modeling and aesthetic cognitivism, the article uses select ideas from model-based science (idealization, parameter variation, counterfactual exploration) heuristically to illuminate how marbling fosters understanding through embodied simulation, imagination, and material engagement - without claiming that marbling is scientific modeling or serves scientific aims. Techniques such as ebru and suminagashi are not merely decorative; they foreground analogical, dynamic exploration of complex material behavior. By enabling counterfactual reasoning, perceptual insight, and tactile grasp of uncertainty, marbling exemplifies a “marbled epistemology” - a fluid mode of knowing that softens the perceived art–science divide by clarifying how artistic practice yields understanding. By “divide” here I mean a difference in aims and norms (truth-tracking explanation versus aesthetic, experiential insight), not an ontological wall between domains.

• Details
• Contents