Senses of objectivity. Henri Poincaré and Ernst Cassirer in the context of structural realism Cover Image

Senses of objectivity. Henri Poincaré and Ernst Cassirer in the context of structural realism
Senses of objectivity. Henri Poincaré and Ernst Cassirer in the context of structural realism

Author(s): Damian Luty
Subject(s): History of Philosophy, Philosophical Traditions
Published by: Instytut Filozofii Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego
Keywords: Henri Poincaré; Ernst Cassirer; epistemic structural realism; ontic structural realism; conventionalism; idealism; realism; objectivity

Summary/Abstract: The goal of the paper is to, at least partly, justify the rejection of what I term the thesis of the origins of structural realism. This thesis deals with the connections, postulated by a certain metaphilosophical narrative, between the contemporary positions of epistemic/ontic structural realism and the views held by physicists and philosophers from the early 20th century. In the paper I summarize the above-mentioned positions and the relationships they are supposed to have enjoyed with the philosophy of Henri Poincaré and Ernst Cassirer. I then proceed to illustrate why such relationships are ill-founded and present conclusions about the unique nature of both structural realism and the notions of objectivity and reality in their context.

  • Issue Year: 18/2021
  • Issue No: 67
  • Page Range: 54-70
  • Page Count: 17
  • Language: English