Literature and Truth: Revisiting Stolnitz’s Anti-cognitivism
Literature and Truth: Revisiting Stolnitz’s Anti-cognitivism
Author(s): Iris VidmarSubject(s): Epistemology, Aesthetics, Theory of Literature
Published by: KruZak
Keywords: Art; cognitivism; knowledge; literature; Jerome Stolnitz; truth;
Summary/Abstract: In this paper I address Jerome Stolnitz’s famous article “On the cognitive triviality of art,” with the aim of defending aesthetic and literary cognitivism against the charges Stolnitz issues at it therein. My defence of literary cognitivism is grounded in contemporary epistemology, which, I argue, is more embracive of cognitive values of literature traditionally invoked by literary cognitivists. My discussion is structured against Stolnitz’s individual arguments, dedicated in particular to the problem of literary truth. After exploring what such notion might amount to, I move on to address the problems of applicability and triviality of literary truths, and I end by defending literature as a cognitively valuable social practice.
Journal: Croatian Journal of Philosophy
- Issue Year: XIX/2019
- Issue No: 56
- Page Range: 351-370
- Page Count: 20
- Language: English
- Content File-PDF