Analysis of CAMEL, Z-Score, and Bankometer in Assessment Soundness of Banking Listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) from 2012-2015
Analysis of CAMEL, Z-Score, and Bankometer in Assessment Soundness of Banking Listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) from 2012-2015

Summary/Abstract: This study analyses the soundness of banking companies listed in the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) during the period of 2012-2015 using CAMEL, Z-Score and Bankometer analysis tools. The study aims to find the differences and appropriate analytical tools that can be used in analysing the health of a banking company in Indonesia. Existing samples in this study were 23 banking firms. After analysing the financial statements and calculating the variables, research showed that there were differences from each analysis tool. According to the results of the analysis of CAMEL throughout the years 2012-2015, there is diverse soundness of the banking firm. There is a healthy bank, banks are quite healthy and there are less healthy banks. Then from the analysis of the Z-Score results using the same timeframe, results show there was no sound bank, but that the bank is in a grey area (grey zone) and there are some banks that have a strong potential for bankruptcy. While the results of the analysis from Bankometer indicated that during 2012-2015, all banks are in a healthy condition. Based on the results of research and analysis conducted, the analytical tools that can be used to analyse the health of banking in Indonesia is CAMEL. Z-Score analysis and Bankometer are options that can be used to supplement the results of the analysis of CAMEL; they cannot be used to replace the CAMEL tool, just remain complementary.

• Details
• Contents