Liberalism, Communitarianism or Republicanism: Critical Objections Regarding Petitts Defense of Republicanism Cover Image

Liberalizam, komunitarizam ili republikanizam: Kritičke primjedbe uz Petittovu obranu republikanizma
Liberalism, Communitarianism or Republicanism: Critical Objections Regarding Petitts Defense of Republicanism

Author(s): Miomir Matulović
Subject(s): Political Philosophy, Political Theory, Government/Political systems
Published by: Fakultet političkih znanosti u Zagrebu
Keywords: liberalism; communitarianism; republicanism; Philip Pettit;

Summary/Abstract: The author presents Petitt’s reaction to the central dichotomy that ensues from MacIntyre’s thinking about politics on the borderline between the liberal thought (as the continuation of the Enlightenment) and the communitarian thought (Aristotelianism-inspired but characteristic of the anti-enlightenment, romantic tradition). Petitt considers that dichotomy mystifying, since it conceals other interesting alternatives, such as pre-liberal, republican political thought. He tries to prove the republican tradition worthy of serious consideration and claims that it can be evolved into a truly appealing political stance. The author concisely describes liberalism and communitarianism as seen by MacIntyre and Petitt. Then he goes on to describe republicanism, as seen by Petitt. And finally, the author lists critical objections to Petitt’s description of republicanism due to which that political alternative does not seem as attractive as Petitt claims.

  • Issue Year: XXXII/1995
  • Issue No: 01
  • Page Range: 89-98
  • Page Count: 10
  • Language: Croatian