J. M. Bocheński’s Definition of the Concept of Nation. A Critique and Analysis from the Pragmatic-Logical Point of View Cover Image

Definicja pojęcia „narodu” u J. M. Bocheńskiego. Analiza pragmatyczno-logiczna i krytyka
J. M. Bocheński’s Definition of the Concept of Nation. A Critique and Analysis from the Pragmatic-Logical Point of View

Author(s): Piotr M. Sękowski
Subject(s): Philosophy
Published by: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego
Keywords: Józef Bocheński; nation; definition of a nation; idea of a nation; Polish nation; fallacies of definition

Summary/Abstract: The article offers an analysis of Józef Bocheński's studies of the concept of nation. Bocheński acknowledges that there are difficulties in defining a nation. After that he claims that he will attempt to propose a definition of the Polish nation. Nation (in particular, the Polish nation) is a social group centered around some cultural ideal. The analysis shows that Bocheński did not avoid serious logical problems. First of all, he constantly falls into a circular reasoning. Furthermore, it is called into question if it makes sense to refer to a cultural ideal or ideology while defining a nation. Is not such an attempt essentially bound to become circular? A doubt is also raised whether nowadays, in the face of constant migration of people and cultural ideals, one can continue to reasonably talk about nations.

  • Issue Year: 2016
  • Issue No: 48
  • Page Range: 89-104
  • Page Count: 16
  • Language: Polish