Indictment and Grand Jury Debates in Nineteenth Century Hungary Cover Image

Indictment and Grand Jury Debates in Nineteenth Century Hungary
Indictment and Grand Jury Debates in Nineteenth Century Hungary

Author(s): Anna Éva Tamási
Subject(s): History of Law, Criminal Law, Recent History (1900 till today), 19th Century, Court case, Comparative Law
Published by: Evropská společnost pro právní dějiny, z.s.
Keywords: Hungarian legal history; criminal procedure; indictment; grand jury; indictment chamber; nineteenth century; codification; Hungary; comparative law; jury system

Summary/Abstract: This paper analyses indictment procedures in nineteenth-century Hungary, focusing on debates over the introduction of the grand jury. It examines the stages of criminal procedural codification and compares the grand jury with the indictment chamber in a broader European context. Drawing on primary sources and contemporary legal opinions, the study explains why, despite significant support, the grand jury was ultimately rejected. The main reasons included the lack of domestic tradition, concerns about legal expertise, financial costs, and the specific social conditions of Hungary. Instead, Hungarian legislators adopted the indictment chamber as a more suitable solution within the continental legal system.

  • Issue Year: 17/2026
  • Issue No: 1
  • Page Range: 174-181
  • Page Count: 8
  • Language: English
Toggle Accessibility Mode