Некоторые криминалистические проблемы производства проверки показаний на месте с участием несовершеннолетнего
Some criminalistic problems of on-site testimony verification involving minor participants
Author(s): R. I. ZainullinSubject(s): Criminal Law, Criminology, Sociology of Law
Published by: Казанский (Приволжский) федеральный университет
Keywords: criminal proceedings; preliminary investigation; criminalistic tactics; investigative action; on-site testimony verification; minor; preparatory stage; interrogation; video recording; purpose of the investigative action;
Summary/Abstract: Given the large number of crimes committed by minors, despite the downward trend in their dynamics, the involvement of minor offenders in criminal proceedings as a distinct group of procedural actors has become inevitable. Accordingly, the state is facing a pressing need to ensure that minors enter the criminal justice system in a way that is safe and takes into account their cognitive, moral, and psychological characteristics. Achieving this requires a robust scientific support for the process of preliminary investigation and the full range of investigative procedures in which minor suspects or witnesses take part. However, while some investigative practices have been well-supported by scholarly research, others, such as on-site verification of testimony when minors are involved, remain underexplored. The emergence of minors as a special category of participants in on-site testimony verification introduces many criminalistic problems that must be addressed. Here, some of the most common criminalistic difficulties encountered by law enforcement officials and demanding scholarly solutions were examined in order to develop practical recommendations. The recommendations were formulated using the identified system of theoretical and applied provisions, as well as considering the results of the analysis of the empirical base, which summarized data on 20 criminal cases with minors involved in the on-site testimony verification procedures and the anonymous survey of 15 investigators, each with at least two years of professional experience.
Journal: Ученые записки Казанского университета. Серия Гуманитарные науки
- Issue Year: 167/2025
- Issue No: 3
- Page Range: 152-162
- Page Count: 11
- Language: Russian
