NEUHVATLJIVA SREĆA: KONTEKSTUALISTIČKO REŠENJE GETIJEOVSKOG PROBLEMA
ELUSIVE LUCK: CONTEXTUALIST APPROACH TO THE GETTIER PROBLEM

Summary/Abstract: Lewisˈ philosophical ambition to eradicate the skeptical threat towards infallibilism was the driving force behind his contextualist approach to knowledge. One of the discerning characteristics of his conversational contextualism is the claim that it can solve the Gettier problem. The first part of this paper will be directed towards explicating the arguments Lewis employed in reaching said solution. The second part will be concerned with Cohen’s critique of the proposed explanation. Cohen’s considerations result in an insight that contextualism does not have the adequate means to answer the Gettier challenge. Finally, I shall make an attempt at further motivating Cohen’s claim by investigating the essential component of Gettier cases - epistemic luck. This will be done by appealing to Pritchard’s concept of veritic epistemic luck. The author’s goal is to suggest that contextualist resources are neither suitable to solve nor exhaustively articulate the Gettier problem.

• Details
• Contents